“We handle your reviews” does not tell you whether a supplier can promise a refund, admit your kitchen made someone ill, or publish a reply before your manager checks the booking record.
Those are three different permissions. A useful restaurant review management service agreement separates them before anyone gets access to your profiles.
The timing matters. BrightLocal’s 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey puts response expectations in focus: leaving replies to an undefined “when we can” process is not a workable scope. Toast’s separate guest-facing AI survey adds context for keeping humans involved in complaint handling—but it does not evaluate outsourced review services. Neither study establishes what authority you should give a supplier.
That requires an operational decision, written down.
The fictional proposal: seven promises with the missing decisions exposed
The following is an explicitly fictional, one-page supplier proposal for three fictional restaurants trading as Rowan Table. Northline Reviews, the supplier, is also fictional.
Strikethrough shows deleted wording. Bold text supplies the replacement. This is a service-scope edit, not legal drafting.
1. “All your reviews” needs a boundary
We handle all your online reviews and protect your reputation.
Northline monitors and responds to new Google Business Profile and Tripadvisor reviews for Rowan Table’s three listed locations. Social comments, delivery-app reviews, direct messages, profile edits, review-removal appeals, and older unanswered reviews are excluded unless added to the scope. Rowan Table retains ownership of every account; Northline receives named-user access, never shared owner credentials.
“All” is expensive shorthand. If your restaurant reputation service excludes a delivery platform where complaints regularly arrive, you need to know that before the first monthly report.
2. “Promptly” needs a clock
Our team responds promptly, seven days a week.
Coverage runs daily, 9 a.m.–6 p.m., in the restaurants’ local time zone. Northline checks both platforms at least every two covered hours. Replies within its publishing authority are published within four covered hours of detection. Other drafts are sent for approval within four covered hours. Outside coverage, work resumes at 9 a.m.; this is not a 24-hour emergency service.
This separates monitoring, drafting, and publishing. A supplier cannot guarantee a publication deadline when your approval is still outstanding.
3. “Your brand voice” is not publishing authority
We reply in your brand voice without taking up your team’s time.
Northline may publish replies without individual approval only when a review contains praise and no complaint, factual dispute, compensation request, or safety concern. Replies must use the approved tone guide and verified location facts. All other replies require approval of the exact text from Rowan Table’s operations manager or named deputy. Silence is not approval.
A five-star review can still say, “Lovely staff, but you charged us twice.” Routing by star rating alone would miss the complaint.
4. “We investigate” needs an owner with access to facts
We investigate complaints and resolve issues professionally.
Northline requests the facts needed to draft a response; Rowan Table checks booking, payment, shift, and incident records. The operations manager confirms those facts and approves the wording within one business day. Northline does not invent explanations, identify employees publicly, or state that a complaint is resolved without confirmation. If approval is late, Northline sends one reminder and records the reply as blocked.
For outsourced restaurant review management, this is the critical division: the supplier owns the response workflow; your restaurant owns the underlying facts.
5. “Make it right” needs a compensation limit—and a safety route
Where appropriate, we offer compensation and deal sensitively with serious complaints.
Northline has no authority to promise or issue refunds, vouchers, discounts, complimentary meals, or reimbursement: its compensation limit is $0. Only the operations manager or deputy may authorize a specific offer, which restaurant staff fulfil privately. Compensation is never conditional on changing or removing a review.
Allegations involving food safety, allergens, injury, discrimination, threats, or legal action are escalated to the operations manager and deputy within one covered hour of detection. Northline publishes nothing on those cases without explicit approval, including holding replies. Rowan Table owns investigation, guest contact, and any emergency or reporting action.
An apology, a factual admission, and a refund offer are not interchangeable. Your review response approval process must distinguish them.
6. “Quality assurance” needs a correction owner
Every response is checked for quality and accuracy.
Northline checks the location, guest name if used, tone, approved facts, and permissions before publication. Northline owns corrections to its published replies. Once an error is detected or reported, it notifies Rowan Table and corrects the reply within two covered hours; disputed facts require manager confirmation first. Material corrections acknowledge the earlier error. The activity log retains the original text, approval, publication time, and correction.
“Please ask Google to fix it” is not an acceptable handoff when the supplier published the mistake.
7. “Easy cancellation” needs an exit deliverable
You can leave whenever you like, with no disruption.
On the agreed service-end date, Northline stops publishing. Within three business days, it supplies an export of review links, drafts, published replies, approvals, correction history, and open cases with named next owners. It also transfers the current tone guide and workflow notes. Rowan Table removes supplier access after checking the handover. Any temporary account restriction is flagged before service ends.
You should not have to reconstruct six months of review management responsibilities from an inbox after the supplier leaves.
The clean operational scope
Remove the sales promises and editing marks, and the working scope becomes short enough for your manager to use:
Accounts and access. Northline covers new Google Business Profile and Tripadvisor reviews for Rowan Table’s three locations. Other channels, historical backlog, profile edits, and removal appeals are excluded. Rowan Table owns the accounts and grants named-user access.
Coverage and timing. Coverage is daily, 9 a.m.–6 p.m. local time, with checks at least every two covered hours. Authorized replies are published—and approval-required drafts submitted—within four covered hours of detection. Work outside coverage resumes at 9 a.m.
Publishing and factual approval. Northline may independently answer praise-only reviews using approved guidance. Every other reply needs exact-text approval from the operations manager or deputy. The restaurant verifies records and facts within one business day. Silence never authorizes publication; overdue approvals receive one reminder and remain logged as blocked.
Compensation and serious complaints. Supplier compensation authority is $0. Restaurant management authorizes specific offers; restaurant staff fulfil them privately. Nothing is offered in exchange for review changes. Safety, discrimination, threat, injury, and legal allegations go to both named managers within one covered hour. No response is published without explicit approval.
Corrections and records. Northline checks replies before publication, maintains the activity log, and owns corrections within two covered hours of detection or notification. Disputed facts await restaurant confirmation. Material corrections acknowledge the error.
Exit. Publishing stops on the agreed end date. Within three business days, Northline delivers the response history, approvals, drafts, open cases, guidance, and named next owners. Rowan Table checks the handover and removes access.
That is the operational test: someone covering your manager’s day off should be able to tell who may publish, who must verify, who may spend, and who takes over next—without calling the salesperson.